When Jaye Tyler is convinced by a waxed lion to chase after a shinny quarter, she finds herself returning a lost purse to a lady (who instead of thanking her, is punched in the face), meeting an attractive and sweet bartender names Eric, introducing her sister, Sharon to the EPS newly divorced bachelor, Thomas, she knows, and later discovering her sister, Sharon`s sexuality.
While working another shift, Jaye is approached by a young girl who, after an introduction, tells her that she stole her wallet. As she gives it back to her, Jaye notices that she has a stuttering problem and a stuffed chameleon tells her to "get her words out".
Jaye and Eric find a woman in the Barrel, who they discover is a nun that is trying to leave her abby. A priest comes looking for her to try to convince her to come back, but isn`t very successful in doing so. Jaye naturally gets wrapped up in it, and taking instructions from the animals, eventually helps the two.
Jaye follows an advice from the cow creamer at the breakfast table, which leads to the arrest of the Tyler`s houskeeper by immergration authorithies, at the same time Jaye`s brother sees her talking to the cow creamer, and begins to question her state of mind.
An old celebrity Millie Markus drops into town to reminisce about being the first woman to ride in a barrel over the falls and survive. Only, she wasn`t. Vivian, the real one who went over the falls, calls her bluff.
Jaye is spying on her neighbour "fat pat", while her other neighbour Mrs Beatle, hasn`t got her disability checks in months, and as a result is having money trouble. Jaye discovers that she accidentally has recieved her mail but the buffalo on Mrs Beatle`s muffin apron orders Jaye not to give her the disability checks.
Jaye and Eric, now officially dating delve a little deeper into thier relationships. But Jaye, under the influence of the talking things that don`t talk, snaps a photo of 2 birds which sets in motion a bird napping, a brother and best friend challenging, Jaye questioning her relationship with Eric and a zoologist and janitor`s relationship.
Heidi, Eric`s wife, shows up and wreaks havok on he and Jaye`s relationship. Meanwhile, fed up with the things that don`t talk, Jaye convinces her brother to take all the talking animals from her. Jaye`s mom goes out on a date and everything comes to a head.
As Eric and Heidi`s marrage tries to get back on track. Jaye spirals wildly out of control as the muses convince her that she must "Save Him From Her", save him from the fact that some is going to murder him. To deal with things, she visits the family`s therapist
Jaye, Sharon and Mahandra visit a nearby Indian reservation, where the spirit of a dead grandmother send all three on a new path towards easing Jaye`s burden. Aaron and Jaye continue on this path and hilarity ensues.
Jaye, Sharon, mouth-breather and the local security guard get held hostage at Wonderfalls. In the meantime, everyone evaluates their relationships as Jaye`s parents start to prep for their anniversary.